The Bottom Five Percent

by Chad Aldeman on July 23, 2010

in Accountability

President Obama has asked states to identify and turnaround or close the bottom 5 percent of persistently low-performing schools. He has asked each federal agency to identify their bottom 5 percent of discretionary programs. And today, his Secretary of Education announced plans to cut off the bottom 5 percent of for-profit higher education training programs from federal financial aid programs. This is officially a trend with this Administration.

On one hand, it’s a relatively arbitrary decision. In many cases, there aren’t noticeable differences between a school or program falling at 4.9 percent versus one that falls at 5.1. On the other hand, it’s a clear message that schools and programs must have continuous improvement, because this year’s 6th-10th percentile becomes next year’s bottom five. It’s also a smart move for Obama to apply the same bottom five percent rule to federal agencies, because it shows he’s not just imposing the pain of turnarounds and closures on schools, but is also bringing the same rhetoric to his employees and the federal budget.

{ 2 comments }

melody July 24, 2010 at 9:33 pm

Continuous improvement? No. What’s going to happen is that the same 25% or so of schools that happen to be in the less wealthy areas are going to be continually recycled into the hopper.

Bob Stan July 23, 2010 at 11:56 am

Several lenders in Scandinavia provide 30 years fixed loans for only 4 percent.

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: